Tuesday, February 16, 2021

Term Limits is a Bad Idea for Democracy

 

Term limits destroys the relationship between the office holder and voters of the district.

During the office holder’s term, he or she has less responsibility to the constituents because they will not be held accountable through elections.  Therefore, the office holder can either vote as he pleases, vote according to the people and organizations that give him money or according to the dictates of the party. 

Part of the office holder’s responsibility is to establish and nurture a relationship for voters of the district with other elected office holders and with members of the government.  If the member’s time in office is legally limited, those around him do not feel compelled to allow a relationship to develop.

Members of Congress will not be making decisions that are responsible to the voters of the district.  If the elected office seat is vacant every few terms, the party in power, those that are employed by the government and/or the lobbyists will have more power. 

An individual voter cannot vote for those that they believe are best suited for the job because Term Limits reduced the pool of people who can run for office.  Even if the voter writes in someone that is term limited out of office, their vote will not count. This destroys the one man one vote concept that democracies and republics are built on.

The Constitution does not mention Term Limits but that does not mean the Founders were not aware of Term Limits.  The foundation to the Constitution is the voter.  After debating the issue, they decided to allow voters to make the decision about how long a member of Congress can serve.     

Term limits here in Michigan has not corrected any problems by term limiting members of the legislature or the executive offices.  If anything, they have made the process worse. 

With term limits, parties hold the power over seats, not individuals.  Individuals that are going to be around care about their district.  Parties care about the party.

Leadership will suffer with term limits.  No one, on either side, will be able to provide benevolent leadership because they are not around long enough to develop relationships with other members of congress.

If we term limit our federal office holders, that will place Michigan are a severe disadvantage compared to other states.

With a short term, office holders do not have time to build a strong relationship with voters in their district, so they become risk adverse.  If they were around long enough, they would be willing and able to cash in some of their credibility to make a choice that is good for the district and the country, even if a majority in the district are against the choice.

Term limits is just another tool the minority governing party wants us to agree with so that they can force out those from an opposing party and have the opportunity to place their own in the position.

Therefore, because term limits lessen the responsibility of the office holder to the constituents, reduces the relationship building, moves more power to the party, government officials and lobbyist and limits a voter’s speech, term limits should not be supported.

 

Tuesday, January 19, 2021

Incitement is not Protected Speech

Incitement is not protected speech. 

There is a GOP talking point about Trump’s impeachment.

It goes like this, the insurrectionist that breached the capitol building are solely responsible for their actions. 

This point also continues that Trump was just exercising his free speech as protected by the Constitution when he told them to go to the capitol building.

It is true that Trump as well as every other citizen in the country has the right to free speech and cannot be held responsible for what they say.   The protection is found in the First Amendment of the Constitution.

Well, with some exceptions.

The United States Supreme Court has carved out some exceptions to the amendment.

The court has carved out commercial speech, obscenity, copywrite and Incitement (advocacy of illegal action).

Trump’s rally in the Capital that day, had plenty of speakers that used strong and aggressive language to excite the crowd and implying that they need to “fight” to protect their rights and the country.

When Trump then appeared on stage, he echoed and reinforced the “fighting” suggestions.  In his closing statement he told them to go to the capitol building and fight for their rights.  When he said he would be there with them it was an endorsement of whatever actions they take.

Trump incited the crowd at the rally with the words of the speakers that proceeded him and his own. 

Incitement is not protected speech and Trump should be held responsible for his words and actions.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fighting_words

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/advocacy_of_illegal_action

Thursday, January 7, 2021

List of Those that Voted to Overthrow the Government of the United States

 

When a mob of President Trump’s supporters stormed the Capitol building on Wednesday, they forced an emergency recess in the Congressional proceedings to officially certify the results of the 2020 presidential election. The disruption came shortly after some Republican lawmakers made the first of a planned series of highly unusual objections, based on spurious allegations of widespread voter fraud, to states’ election results. The chambers were separately debating an objection to Arizona’s results when proceedings were halted and the Capitol was locked down.

When the Senate reconvened at 8 p.m., and the House of Representatives an hour later, the proceedings — including the objection debates — continued, although some lawmakers who had previously planned to vote with the objectors stood down following the occupation of the Capitol. Plans to challenge a number of states after Arizona were scrapped, as well — but one other objection, to Pennsylvania’s results, also advanced to a vote. Here are the eight senators and 139 representatives who voted to sustain one or both objections.

Senate

 

Tommy Tuberville, Ala.

 

Rick Scott, Fla.

 

Roger Marshall, Kan.

 

John Kennedy, La.

 

Cindy Hyde-Smith, Miss.

 

Josh Hawley, Mo.

 

Ted Cruz, Texas

 

Cynthia Lummis, Wyo.

House

 

Robert B. Aderholt, Ala.

 

Mo Brooks, Ala.

 

Jerry Carl, Ala.

 

Barry Moore, Ala.

 

Gary Palmer, Ala.

 

Mike Rogers, Ala.

 

Andy Biggs, Ariz.

 

Paul Gosar, Ariz.

 

Debbie Lesko, Ariz.

 

David Schweikert, Ariz.

 

Rick Crawford, Ark.

 

Ken Calvert, Calif.

 

Mike Garcia, Calif.

 

Darrell Issa, Calif.

 

Doug LaMalfa, Calif.

 

Kevin McCarthy, Calif.

 

Devin Nunes, Calif.

 

Jay Obernolte, Calif.

 

Lauren Boebert, Colo.

 

Doug Lamborn, Colo.

 

Kat Cammack, Fla.

 

Mario Diaz-Balart, Fla.

 

Byron Donalds, Fla.

 

Neal Dunn, Fla.

 

Scott Franklin, Fla.

 

Matt Gaetz, Fla.

 

Carlos Gimenez, Fla.

 

Brian Mast, Fla.

 

Bill Posey, Fla.

 

John Rutherford, Fla.

 

Greg Steube, Fla.

 

Daniel Webster, Fla.

 

Rick Allen, Ga.

 

Earl L. "Buddy" Carter, Ga.

 

Andrew Clyde, Ga.

 

Marjorie Taylor Greene, Ga.

 

Jody Hice, Ga.

 

Barry Loudermilk, Ga.

 

Russ Fulcher, Idaho

 

Mike Bost, Ill.

 

Mary Miller, Ill.

 

Jim Baird, Ind.

 

Jim Banks, Ind.

 

Greg Pence, Ind.

 

Jackie Walorski, Ind.

 

Ron Estes, Kan.

 

Jacob LaTurner, Kan.

 

Tracey Mann, Kan.

 

Harold Rogers, Ky.

 

Garret Graves, La.

 

Clay Higgins, La.

 

Mike Johnson, La.

 

Steve Scalise, La.

 

Andy Harris, Md.

 

Jack Bergman, Mich.

 

Lisa McClain, Mich.

 

Tim Walberg, Mich.

 

Michelle Fischbach, Minn.

 

Jim Hagedorn, Minn.

 

Michael Guest, Miss.

 

Trent Kelly, Miss.

 

Steven Palazzo, Miss.

 

Sam Graves, Mo.

 

Vicky Hartzler, Mo.

 

Billy Long, Mo.

 

Blaine Luetkemeyer, Mo.

 

Jason Smith, Mo.

 

Matt Rosendale, Mont.

 

Dan Bishop, N.C.

 

Ted Budd, N.C.

 

Madison Cawthorn, N.C.

 

Virginia Foxx, N.C.

 

Richard Hudson, N.C.

 

Gregory F. Murphy, N.C.

 

David Rouzer, N.C.

 

Jeff Van Drew, N.J.

 

Yvette Herrell, N.M.

 

Chris Jacobs, N.Y.

 

Nicole Malliotakis, N.Y.

 

Elise M. Stefanik, N.Y.

 

Lee Zeldin, N.Y.

 

Adrian Smith, Neb.

 

Steve Chabot, Ohio

 

Warren Davidson, Ohio

 

Bob Gibbs, Ohio

 

Bill Johnson, Ohio

 

Jim Jordan, Ohio

 

Stephanie Bice, Okla.

 

Tom Cole, Okla.

 

Kevin Hern, Okla.

 

Frank Lucas, Okla.

 

Markwayne Mullin, Okla.

 

Cliff Bentz, Ore.

 

John Joyce, Pa.

 

Fred Keller, Pa.

 

Mike Kelly, Pa.

 

Daniel Meuser, Pa.

 

Scott Perry, Pa.

 

Guy Reschenthaler, Pa.

 

Lloyd Smucker, Pa.

 

Glenn Thompson, Pa.

 

Jeff Duncan, S.C.

 

Ralph Norman, S.C.

 

Tom Rice, S.C.

 

William Timmons, S.C.

 

Joe Wilson, S.C.

 

Tim Burchett, Tenn.

 

Scott DesJarlais, Tenn.

Chuck Fleischmann, Tenn.

 

Mark E. Green, Tenn.

 

Diana Harshbarger, Tenn.

 

David Kustoff, Tenn.

 

John Rose, Tenn.

 

Jodey Arrington, Texas

 

Brian Babin, Texas

 

Michael C. Burgess, Texas

 

John R. Carter, Texas

 

Michael Cloud, Texas

 

Pat Fallon, Texas

 

Louie Gohmert, Texas

 

Lance Gooden, Texas

 

Ronny Jackson, Texas

 

Troy Nehls, Texas

 

August Pfluger, Texas

 

Pete Sessions, Texas

 

Beth Van Duyne, Texas

 

Randy Weber, Texas

 

Roger Williams, Texas

 

Ron Wright, Texas

 

Burgess Owens, Utah

 

Chris Stewart, Utah

 

Ben Cline, Va.

 

Bob Good, Va.

 

Morgan Griffith, Va.

 

Robert J. Wittman, Va.

 

Carol Miller, W.Va.

 

Alexander X. Mooney, W.Va.

 

Scott Fitzgerald, Wis.

 

Tom Tiffany, Wis.